JPendleton
November 4, 2026

When I first heard that Charlie Kirk had been shot, I immediately thought that this had to have been a robbery attempt or something of that nature. It never crossed my mind that this could be an assassination attempt. Once I saw the footage, I knew two things immediately: Charlie Kirk was dead, and this was clearly an assassination.
It immediately hit me that I completely underestimated and ignored Charlie Kirk’s influence on the MAGA-Donald Trump political movement. Ironically, it was a willful choice on my part–I stopped listening to Charlie after Trump’s first term, ironically, due to his loyalty to Israel and other neoconservative voices. Once I started listening to his commentary for the year prior to his death, my hairs stood up. My gut clenched. I felt sick to my stomach. I had ignored this young man, for no good reason. I always knew he was highly intelligent, but his political alliances and quick rise to popularity had me questioning his intentions and purpose. Now, to me it is clear that Charlie Kirk was flawed-he was human. He made mistakes. And he changed his opinions over time as he learned new things. Charlie never stopped trying to learn, which was why he was so intelligent. He was beginning to pivot on his views of Israel and neoconservatism.
In hindsight, I realize I was jealous of his political influence. There was a time when I was Charlie’s age during his college years, during the Ron Paul era, that I wanted that type of political influence. Charlie often made the same moral and political arguments that I was advocating for at the time, and continue to do so to this day.
When Charlie Kirk was publicly murdered for the world to see, my first feelings were accurate, and honest. Something changed. “The multiple assassination attempts on President Trump, now this,” I said. It didn’t make sense. It wasn’t believable.
And neither was President Trump’s complete 180 on the Epstein files. Most of MAGA knew something was terribly wrong the moment President Trump proclaimed: “Epstein? We’re still talking about that guy?!” This was the first red flag for what was to come in Trump’s second term.
There were immediate questions from the recorded footage of Charlie Kirk’s death. The first observation many made was the old man who stood up with his pants down, claiming he had taken the shot that took Charlie’s life. George Zinn’s performance that day was a great distraction. Then, the young man who stood up and cheered immediately after Charlie hit the floor, cheered his death. It immediately reminded me of the scenes of the JFK assassination. Planning. Coordination. Accuracy.
The official narrative that Tyler Robinson, a purported trans-obsessed insane lone gunman took the shot, was accepted by most. Including myself, initially. Trans violence is at an all-time high in this country, and Charlie Kirk would be the perfect target for an angry insane trans person.
Then, came the public memorial. The memorial for Charlie Kirk held a tone and display environment that was expected up to a certain point. The crowd, the stage, the music, the high-profile attendees from MAGA’s best. However, there were several key moments that took my emotions from pain and sadness to pure anger, almost immediately.
The first moment was Lee Greenwood singing “God Bless, the USA.” Why would that enrage me? Well, it is because Lee has been a staple for the majority of Trump’s campaign rallies, whether he was present, or not. I immediately sensed that this was a production, not a memorial. The tears stopped–and I started paying closer attention to what I was seeing.
Then, enter Erika Kirk. The firework display. The dress. The awkward embrace with President Trump, where I could swear I saw Trump instruct Erika to look up at Charlie’s photograph hanging from the rafters, as her performative emotional display was clearly over the top, and distracting. It was as if Trump was conducting one of his pageants. And looking back–it is clear that is exactly what he was doing.
For me, that is the exact moment that MAGA died as a political movement.
What has happened since, validates that assertion. Charlie Kirk was clearly against the war in Iran for many reasons. He saw through Israel’s propaganda campaign, he saw the political and economic consequences that would follow. It only took 171 days from Charlie’s assassination on September 10, 2025, for President Trump to ignore Charlie’s concerns by striking Iran on February 28, 2026.
Charlie knew this would be a serious violation of the MAGA movement’s core principles and campaign promises offered by President Trump and his team. Charlie knew that the first violation occurred when President Trump ignored the palpable anger toward the Epstein criminal pedophile network. So much for draining the Swamp.
Charlie was MAGA. Charlie held true to his beliefs and political aspirations for America, while the leaders he put trust in violated their campaign promises. Charlie was the forgotten man that many Trump supporters rightfully identify as. And we all watched as the forgotten man was brutally executed for the world to see.
There are many questions that surround the murder and assassination of Charlie Kirk. Why install concrete pavers at the site of his death, during an active crime scene investigation? Why are there so many discrepancies in the surveillance video footage released by the FBI, police, and Candace Owens? How could a 30.06 round not penetrate through Charlie’s neck, as expected? Those questions hopefully will be answered at a later time. We do know, those questions will likely not be answered during the criminal trial.
Now, with the Midterms approaching, it is clear that Republicans are facing disaster. The “No New Wars” campaign promise was arguably the most important, as America is tired of foreign entanglements in the Middle East. Trump is currently polling at 30%, the lowest approval rating he’s ever had during both terms.
The popularity decline started the moment Charlie Kirk was killed, and continued with the lack of transparency that followed. His disapproval rating has only increased since the start of the Iran War.
The worst part about President Trump’s recent catastrophic failures with the Epstein files, Charlie Kirk assassination messaging, and the Iran war, is that President Trump’s actual victories will be overshadowed.
The Department of Homeland Security reported that FY 2026 encounters were 88% lower than FY 2023 under the previous administration.
President Trump signed the Laken Riley Act on January 29, 2025. The act amends the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA) to require the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) to detain non-U.S. citizens who are unlawfully present and have been arrested for, charged with, convicted of, or admitted to committing:
In his second term, the Trump administration (via Executive Order 14176, signed January 23, 2025) directed the release of remaining assassination-related records. The National Archives (NARA) has published the following:
President Trump and Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth have done a great job removing woke, marxist policies that allowed transgender insanity to infiltrate our military.
President Trump has removed anti-white “Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion” policies throughout the Federal Government.
President Donald Trump signed Executive Order 14201, on February 5, 2025 to ban transgender participation in women’s sports, protecting the sanctity of women’s rights.
The Wall Street Journal reported in June 2026 that Section 232 Steel Tariffs are the most pro-American manufacturing initiative in decades. US steel manufacturing has responded well to President Trump’s tariffs.
The murder of Charlie Kirk did not merely wound the MAGA movement; it exposed its terminal condition. What began as a populist revolt against endless wars, elite impunity, and institutional rot was quietly recaptured by the very forces it claimed to displace. Kirk, for all his earlier missteps, had begun to sound the alarm on those contradictions—warning that campaign rhetoric on Epstein, foreign entanglements, and the forgotten American would not survive contact with the permanent government. His public murder, followed by the rapid pivot to strikes on Iran and the continued opacity surrounding Epstein, confirmed that the warnings were justified. The border enforcement, the Laken Riley Act, the dismantling of DEI, and the release of long-buried assassination files remain real accomplishments. Yet they cannot paper over the abandonment of the central pledges that defined the movement: no new wars and accountability for the powerful. When those core commitments are discarded, the remaining victories become consolation prizes rather than proof of principle.
With midterms results coming in, it appears to be a disaster for Republicans. Approval ratings are at historic lows and the political consequences are already visible. The base that once saw itself in Kirk—skeptical of neoconservative orthodoxy and unwilling to subordinate American interests to foreign capitals—has been left without a clear standard-bearer who will defend those priorities under pressure. Movements survive the loss of individual leaders when the ideas they championed remain intact and the leaders who inherit them refuse to reverse course. In this case, the opposite occurred. The question is no longer whether MAGA as it was known can be revived under present leadership. The question is whether the Americans who once formed its core will insist on principles that outlast any single administration, or whether they will accept that the revolt has been managed into something safer for the institutions it once threatened.
Joseph Pendleton is an author and conservatarian pundit based in Denver, Colorado.
The Death of MAGA (and Charlie Kirk): An Autopsy on the Populist Conservative Movement that Defined an American Decade © 2026 Joseph Pendleton
ISBN: 978-1-7359851-2-1
This book contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Such material is made available in this for-profit publication to advance understanding of political, social justice, and human rights issues. The author and publisher believe this constitutes a ‘fair use’ of any such copyrighted material as provided for in Section 107 of the US Copyright Law, given that the material is used strictly for purposes such as criticism, commentary, scholarship, and research.